(...)

it really pisses me off when people say they dont know anything about her or she has no personality or shes boring. she is geniuinely the sweetest girl and she actually takes time to read all of her fans questions and shes prepared to take critisism (TWOP). ps this is better than manaleighs wonk eye by a country mile

her top 3 is 1)CoverGirl Shot (this) 2)Bikini Shot 3)Fierce Eyes

IMO her top 3 was 1)Bikini Shot, 2)Award Show, 3)Natural Shot...

i just saw the billboard and this looks stunning blown up to a bigger size. stunning.

The best shot in her portfolio. She looks a little beyond 19, but it def works. It looks like she's selling the Eyelights mascara; my eyes go straight to her eyes!

Oh dear LORD. This photo burns my eyes!!!! I don't understand how you guys can like it! Ick.

This is beautiful.

@ericarapheal555: I kno right?!

i dont hate this. i dont luv it either.

I'm not too crazy about this ad although it's ok. There's just something amiss here...maybe it's the smile or the eyes or maybe the way her hair is styled. She's definitely not a Covergirl...which is on so many levels, a very good thing.

I love this photo so so so so much.

The hair looks too fluffed up/fake/dull/too dark, her mouth is too tense, and she's not selling the makeup. I don't understand why the judges loved it.

this is kind of pretty but too old-looking and too much like a hair-dye box. doesn't make me think of an a top-selling makeup ad. or a new top model

Lazy eye, poofy lips, forced smile, mature looking, just all wrong! /Janice

heres my thoughts on all the winners

This is the best covergirl of all the winners. Caridee's comes close though. This shot is stunning. Analeigh's and Sams's were awful. I'm so glad she won.

For me the best Covergirl shot was Eva's and Danielle's.

I won't get tired of saying how gorgeous this picture is. It's the best out of the three. And as all the commercials were meh, she deserved the first call

I don't get it! I hate this picture of McKey! Her smile is tight and it looks forced, and her nose looks weird. I mean, I never liked McKey in the first place, but she had some pretty kicky photos. Unfortunately this wasn't one of them! I wish Sam would have won. She owns!!! I almost cried when Tyra said McKey name.