I think she was called first because she isn't trying to be modelly pretty in the photo. She was just trying to have fun and be herself in the shoot, and she was the only girl where we got a sense of based on photos, and personally I LOVE THIS
I actually love it. Its very fierce and sexy. LOVE the subtle intensity and sexiness in her eyes. Its like "BROOKE- SEXY AND FIERCE!" Its a completely different side of Brooke.
Not everyone is going to be into her kind of look, but I loved her. And this is the kind of cover shot that would make me look further because she looks so unique.
This definitely deserved to be called first. With the exception of Kari's and maybe Danielle's, this is the only picture that could be a magazine cover. None of the other girls really grasped the concept.
I think she totally works it here, the problem is the lipstick. A natural lip would've worked much better, and would've produced an overall better shot.